Pisces Man Dedicated and Elusive

by RL

I have some observations about Pisces men that seem to match what I have read here so far: Evasive, yes, they can be, but when they come to you, it's positively incredible the connection that's there. Emotion, emotion, emotion. And spontaneity. And recklessness. And genius. And love. And tenderness. And patience. And compassion. And ...wait, I don't understand your behavior, can you please explain it to me? Vibes? Crap, where's my Intellect/Vibe dictionary...?

As an Aquarius woman, I realize that it's difficult for me to show my emotions, but I have sort of broken through that by reminding myself that emotion is Pisces' first language and am attempting to learn it. I started writing how I felt, for starters. I didn't know how far heartfelt words would go with you Fish, nor how meaningful my quirky and unique gifts could be (I was just speaking in my OWN language with that), but I feel more often than not that my man has fallen largely due to these gestures. I even cried in front of him a couple of weeks ago! Cried! Me! I have learned in large part, at least so far, to speak his language. The only problem I face now is to see if he will be willing to learn MINE. As a water-bearer, I want to know why.

I have been dating a Pisces man seriously for a couple of months, and in that time we have both been intimate (fortunately both of us attach heavy emotional meaning to the act and don't engage in it frequently or lightly, so there is more safety than there coule be if sex were casual) and he has also asked for space, though he has come back at the end of it (actually, he asked for a week of space and then called me the next day... what gives??).

So do I take him seriously when he says "I love you" (a phrase he says he doesn't offer unless there's dedication attached to it) and tell myself he'll return after the space, or what? It's really difficult to say whether the relationship is really headed in a permenant direction after so little time (though he knows I want it to be and has reciprocated the same desire - in words, mind you), but I do feel that if we can both work on commuicating in a way that the other understands, then things will work out for the best.

Pisces men, please answer me this:

If you declare yourself to a woman, do you mean it? And if you mean it, does that nullify the petrifying fear I feel that you'll disappear forever when you're rude one day or ask for space the other?

The most consistent feeling over the months with my Pisces man has been affectionate, dedicated and tender, and I am thinking that perhaps these deviations are part of your famous mood swings, so I am not quite ready to dismiss you as too much work. Geez, aren't we ALL too much work sometimes? But, I am a fixed sign, less moody and more logical than you Fish are. The chamelion changeability of you has me quite confused.

So, my last question is, is it worth it? Some days I feel like I'm soaring, others I feel like I'm sinking. More soaring than sinking, over the months, but does it ever level out? And is the risk too great when I (confident and leading Aquarius that I am) have a day where I need you to be there for me??

Last note: I asked my Pisces man to write me a letter telling me how he felt about me. He seemed genuinely interested in winning my heart, so I told him that this, above much else, was a way to do it. That was two months ago. He hasn't written it yet, though I have been patient with him and gently reminded him that I need something concrete to hold onto when he disappears so I don't try to chase him down - I want to just let him do his thing. While all other affection and exclusivity has been present, this letter hasn't. Am I to take this personally, or issue an ultimatim? It's not so much the letter as a need I have expressed that shouldn't take too much out of someone (I would think, but I could be wrong) so leaving it unfulfilled leads me to wonder if I am the one he leans on all the time, or can I have a moment where HE is the stable one and I am leaning?

All in all, it is a wild ride, but not an unfulfilling one. I have never had so much fun, nor wanted to tear my hair out so much in my life.

Thank you for listening.

BTW: Man: Pisces w/ Virgo rising
Woman: Aquarius w/ Libra rising

Comments for Pisces Man Dedicated and Elusive

Click here to add your own comments

Comments from a Pisces man
by: Anonymous

I want to focus on three points you mentioned before. The first is that you made an effort to communicate on his level, which is hard for an aquarius for sure. You made an effort to communicate emotions, but for us Pisces it's not clear what you would mean by asking us to communicate like you or other air signs. Communication is the main difference between the different type of sign elements, so forcing or expecting a sign to communicate like another is tough call. Also, don't ask him to be something he is not.

Second, when he says he needs his space, it does not mean he does not care about you. We Pisces need our space to recharge. Also, Aquarius' energy level is incredibly high, so it's hard for us to keep up.

About the letter, please don't force him this way - we have our own way of expressing love and dedication, so expecting him to do this could back-fire. If he does not write the letter, just let it go - but if you bring it up, just be nice and mellow, and if you get a slight resistance from him, just drop the request, or you will make him start resenting the relationship.

I hope you see that these two signs are very different, so hopefully you both appreciate each other's qualities, instead of trying to make the other change. Good luck!

Thanks for the Advice - Moon signs make the difference!
by: RL

Anonymous,

I appreciate your advice. As it turns out, I did my best to respect my Piscean BF's fluidity and style of communication, but perhaps he is too fluid for me. One important development is my discovery of our respective moon signs:

his is Virgo, mine is Scorpio.

I can say that in this particular relationship, I behaved more like a Scorpio than an Aquarius, and he more like a Virgo than a Pisces, so perhaps our double-mutable, double-fixed signs caused some tension. It is interesting to note that when we broke up and started to communicate again just as friends, I found my Pisces/Virgo in hot emotional pursuit. Since I had very strong feelings for him, I did my best to show my genuine interest by respecting his feelings and not pressing him to disclose what they were, but the more room I gave, the more emotional dependency he expressed.

Now, for a Scorpio, this is a dream come true (and I was elated), except for the "I don't know if I want a relationship with you/I don't even know how I feel about you" part. My Scorpionic moon keeps me loyal to the end, but the solid foundation of "Yes, I like you" required by my fixed nature is where he and I had problems.

Unfortunately, I believe I began to annoy his Virgo sensibilities and he all of the sudden (though more than likely it was stewing for a while) cut off our friendship all together. No contact.

Fine, I will respect it, and I figured it was also a good time to learn from my Fish/Virgin's natural fluidity how to bend more myself. For me, this whole relationship, while it may have been volatile (and I am not excluding my unpredictable Aquarius sun sign nor my moody Scorpio moon), I have learned a great deal about what makes me tick and what things I can change. More fluid I am, more insecure I am not. More open-minded I am, more possessive I am not. I have grown a great deal, even though things didn't last.

I hear that Virgo (and Pisces for that matter) men want what they can't have. While some Scorpios or Aquarians may have no problems manipulating their man with reverse psychology, I have some real difficulty doing that.

So, in the end, I just want to say thank you to all of you dreamy (and sometimes confused) Fish and all of you precise (and sometimes fussy) Virgins for helping me learn more about myself. I hope I was able to return the favor, and I hope that you saw the best in my signs. Heavens knows I see the best in yours.

RL

Thanks for the Advice - Moon signs make the difference!
by: RL

Anonymous,

I appreciate your advice. As it turns out, I did my best to respect my Piscean BF's fluidity and style of communication, but perhaps he is too fluid for me. One important development is my discovery of our respective moon signs:

his is Virgo, mine is Scorpio.

I can say that in this particular relationship, I behaved more like a Scorpio than an Aquarius, and he more like a Virgo than a Pisces, so perhaps our double-mutable, double-fixed signs caused some tension. It is interesting to note that when we broke up and started to communicate again just as friends, I found my Pisces/Virgo in hot emotional pursuit. Since I had very strong feelings for him, I did my best to show my genuine interest by respecting his feelings and not pressing him to disclose what they were, but the more room I gave, the more emotional dependency he expressed.

Now, for a Scorpio, this is a dream come true (and I was elated), except for the "I don't know if I want a relationship with you/I don't even know how I feel about you" part. My Scorpionic moon keeps me loyal to the end, but the solid foundation of "Yes, I like you" required by my fixed nature is where he and I had problems.

Unfortunately, I believe I began to annoy his Virgo sensibilities and he all of the sudden (though more than likely it was stewing for a while) cut off our friendship all together. No contact.

Fine, I will respect it, and I figured it was also a good time to learn from my Fish/Virgin's natural fluidity how to bend more myself. For me, this whole relationship, while it may have been volatile (and I am not excluding my unpredictable Aquarius sun sign nor my moody Scorpio moon), I have learned a great deal about what makes me tick and what things I can change. More fluid I am, more insecure I am not. More open-minded I am, more possessive I am not. I have grown a great deal, even though things didn't last.

I hear that Virgo (and Pisces for that matter) men want what they can't have. While some Scorpios or Aquarians may have no problems manipulating their man with reverse psychology, I have some real difficulty doing that.

So, in the end, I just want to say thank you to all of you dreamy (and sometimes confused) Fish and all of you precise (and sometimes fussy) Virgins for helping me learn more about myself. I hope I was able to return the favor, and I hope that you saw the best in my signs. Heavens knows I see the best in yours.

RL

Oh dear
by: Anonymous

RL - I could have written that entry but you beat me to it! I was too busy pulling my hairs out and being driven up the wall by my Pisces Man. An true blue blooded aquarian like yourself - I'm a free giver of space bec I myself would like to be the receiver of it. I went into this (whatever you call this relationship) w my Pisces man knowing that they are ruled by their emotions and feel things on a whole other level. (my younger sister is a Pisces, so yes, I'm very aware and used to the mood swings.

Insecurity is not in my vocabulary, but during the time we spend apart - THE SPACE - after I've done amusing myself and telling myself not to take it personally: feelings of insecurity creep in. My piscean sister is famous for packing her bags and skipping town ( only to come back when none of us run after her) so you can just imagine how fearful I am that maybe one day, without word or warning? In true pisces style, my man will do the same.

Right now, I don't question. I don't assume. I don't expect but remain supportive, understanding and cheerful.


I don't know how long I can stay in the present for both of us while he is away enjoying his space.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Pisces man.